The sacred text and human opinion: do not mix them up

November 13, 2026 · Minbur منبر

Many arguments among Muslims begin with a hidden mistake: we treat a person's opinion as if it were the word of God. Then every disagreement feels like an attack on religion itself.

Two different things

The Qur'an and the authentic words of the Prophet ﷺ are the source. A scholar's explanation of how to apply them to a new case is ijtihad: serious, valuable, but human. It can be right or it can be wrong. The Prophet ﷺ himself said that a judge who tries hard and is right gets two rewards, and one who tries hard and errs still gets one.

Why this matters

What "applying the Shari'ah" really means

It is often said as a slogan. But applying the Shari'ah is not one law copied from a book. It means making sure justice, honesty, mercy and the protection of people's lives and rights are real in daily life. A rule used to harm the weak while the goal behind it is ignored has missed the point.

A simple habit

When you hear a ruling, ask three friendly questions: what is the evidence, who says so and are they qualified, and do other qualified scholars agree? Then accept that sincere scholars can differ. The old imams said this about themselves: "our view is right but may be wrong; another view is wrong but may be right."

Respecting the text and respecting the right to think are not opposites. Both come from the same faith.

All posts